Skip to main content

Why Don't Publishers Market & Promote the Books They Publish?

Image placeholder title

Over on my Facebook page, I
shared a quote from David Ogilvy:

In
the modern world of business, it is useless to be a creative original
thinker unless you can also sell what you create. Management cannot be
expected to recognize a good idea unless it is presented to them by a
good salesman.

Publishing falls into the modern
world of business, and it's always benefiting through and from creative
original thinkers (one hopes).

The mediocre writer who can sell
is usually more successful than the talented writer who cannot.

Aside
from all other hard truths about publishing, this is the one that many
writers find most difficult to accept. While I was at AWP,
I heard a small press advise the audience: "Writers should stay in a
room in write." Clapping erupted.

Writers certainly can stay in
their room and write if they want to remain in obscurity. That aside,
the thoughtful writer does wonder: Why don't publishers market and
promote their own books? Wouldn't they benefit from it? Wouldn't it make
sense? Aren't THEY supposed to be the experts here? All points well
taken.

Here are a few reasons why publishers don't market and
promote all of the books on their list:

  1. They don't have
    enough money, time, or staff.
  2. They have no means of directly
    reaching the target readership to let people know a book of interest is
    available.
  3. They can't measure the impact of their efforts, thus
    resources get pulled away from marketing.
  4. They hope the book
    finds its audience by simply being available and in stores. (Publishers
    are excellent at physical and retail distribution.)
  5. Did I
    mention they don't have enough money, time, or staff? Now, you would
    probably advise: That means publishers should publish less. I agree! But
    are you, as a writer, ready for even HIGHER rejection rates?

Publishers
are known for putting most of their efforts behind A-list authors, or
behind authors who receive a very large advance, or behind the book that
receives the best response/commitment from the chain booksellers.

Every
other title gets the "standard" treatment, and who knows what THAT is, since it's changing daily given the transformation of media and bookselling
(advertising is often ineffective, reviews and awards don't ensure
sales, press releases are unopened, tours/signings aren't attended,
etc).

What still sells books? That's the nut everyone is
trying to crack. Ideas:

  • Authors who already have established
    followings and can reach their readers directly.
  • E-mail
    promotions to a very targeted list (either a list that the author has
    cultivated or that the publisher is lucky enough to have).
  • National
    media coverage or appearances on TV/radio/magazines, sometimes
    newspapers (tougher and tougher to secure as media outlets consolidate,
    disappear, and carry less authority).
  • Word of mouth resulting from readers who LOVE the book. (Great content, great quality.)

Everyone
in publishing acknowledges the system is not ideal. It is in fact
broken, especially when everyone widely admits that 70%
of books don't earn out their advance.

And now with
publishers facing a digital transformation that will disrupt the
business model even further, we're seeing experimentation and
suggestions of what the future might be like.

Predictions from
others

  1. Publishers will only be able to attract solid
    authors by contractually committing to a certain level of marketing.
  2. Publishers
    will attract solid authors with profit sharing deals, to incentivize
    both sides to market and promote. See this report on a Digital Book
    World panel, "Back-Loaded
    Book Deals."
  3. Publishers will become niche-focused so
    they can more successfully direct market to specific communities. See
    this post from Mike Shatzkin that explains.
  4. Publishers
    will draw down their lists (already happening) and only publish books
    they can fully market. (See HarperStudio as one example,
    sadly now defunct, as well as Karp's
    Twelve
    .)
  5. Publishers of all sizes will make better use of
    their author bases and community power to cross market and promote for
    like gain. See Hay House as an example.

What
do you see happening? Or what marketing efforts HAVE paid off for you
or your publisher?

Also: Here's
a book that helps you be an empowered author no matter how your
publisher markets and promotes your work.

Photo
credit: Troy Holden

Poetry Prompt

Wednesday Poetry Prompts: 629

Every Wednesday, Robert Lee Brewer shares a prompt and an example poem to get things started on the Poetic Asides blog. This week, write an avoidance poem.

What Are Submission Guidelines in Writing?

What Are Submission Guidelines in Writing?

In this post, we answer the question of what are submission guidelines in writing, and we look at how writers can take advantage of them to find more success getting published.

3 Tips for Crafting a Character That Can Carry a Series

3 Tips for Crafting a Character That Can Carry a Series

From planting characteristics early on to understanding the expectations of your genre, author Mia P. Manansala shares 3 tips for crafting a character that can carry a series.

Quite the Reward

Quite the Reward

Every writer needs a little inspiration once in a while. For today's prompt, your character rescues a creature that turns out to be a powerful being.

Rita Zoey Chin: On the Way Storytelling Can Shape Lives

Rita Zoey Chin: On the Way Storytelling Can Shape Lives

Author Rita Zoey Chin discusses the process of writing her new novel, The Strange Inheritance of Leah Fern.

Chess Life: Market Spotlight

Chess Life: Market Spotlight

For this week's market spotlight, we look at Chess Life, the official publication of the United States Chess Federation.

The Art and Craft of Pre-Writing

The Art and Craft of Pre-Writing

What do you do when pantsing leads to false starts but plotting feels less organic? Author Christine Wells shares what she calls the art and craft of pre-writing, and a step-by-step system to help you succeed.

From Script

Learning About Your Characters Through Action (From Script)

In this week’s round up brought to us by Script magazine, read an exclusive interview with Raamla Mohamed, the creator, writer, and EP behind Hulu’s “Reasonable Doubt,” about stating the theme through a pivotal piece of dialogue and laying the groundwork for character development.

Mur Lafferty: On Adding a Science Fiction Spin on the Murder Mystery Novel

Mur Lafferty: On Adding a Science Fiction Spin on the Murder Mystery Novel

Author Mur Lafferty discusses the process of writing hew new science fiction myster novel, Station Eternity.