Skip to main content
Publish date:

Would Mystery Author Agatha Christie Make a Good Amateur Detective?

Would the master of the mystery novel be the master of solving mysteries in real life? Author Colleen Cambridge considers whether or not Agatha Christie would make a good amateur detective.

Agatha Christie is the author of some of the most twisted, cunning, and unexpected murder mysteries, but would she be just as good investigating real-life crimes?

In my new book, Murder at Mallowan Hall, Ms. Christie says certainly not—even when a dead body shows up in her library during a house party. “It’s difficult enough to write the dratted things,” she says when the idea is proposed by her housekeeper and friend Phyllida Bright. “I’m not about to try and follow clues in real life—mainly because I can’t put them where I want them!”

(Colleen Cambridge: On Honoring the Golden Age of Detective Fiction)

As a murder mystery writer myself, I concur with this position. It’s far easier to construct a mystifying puzzle—and a surprise solution—on paper than to attempt to discover clues in real life. After all, we writers are known for going back into our stories to “pepper” them with clues in order to lead our detectives—and readers—to the proper solution. Attempting to find relevant information about actual murders would surely be frustrating—and, let’s be honest, quite boring. Real life crimes rarely have the twisted, unexpected solutions of a Christie novel.

Agatha Christie had plenty of her own real-life drama when she famously disappeared for 11 days, and it seems obvious that, having lived through the ensuing public uproar, she would avoid anything related to newsworthy events—including getting herself involved in investigating a murder. In fact, she was always quite shy, but after her disappearance, she became even more so—and one can hardly blame her, for every interview or story about her after those events always focused on why she went away, what she did, and where she was for those 11 days. She came to dislike the press and publicity—although even in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s, it was expected for a popular writer to participate in the promotion of their works.

Thus, when Phyllida Bright proposes the idea that Agatha should follow in M. Poirot’s or Miss Marple’s footsteps and attempt to find out who murdered someone in the home she shares with her second husband, Max Mallowan, it seems logical that Agatha would shut that idea down quite firmly. In fact, she suggests that Phyllida should take on the investigation—because neither Phyllida nor Agatha want the press hovering about, and clearly the authorities need assistance.

Would Mystery Author Agatha Christie Make a Good Amateur Detective?

IndieBound | Bookshop | Amazon
[WD uses affiliate links.]

Needless to say, Phylllida Bright turns out to be an extremely capable detective. Already with her thumbs on everything happening in the household at Mallowan Hall, she has a built-in opportunity to poke around the guests’ bedchambers, looking for clues. Aside from that, as housekeeper of a very large estate (think "Downton Abbey," although Mallowan Hall is quite fictional), Phyllida is required to be organized, proactive, and very efficient—all characteristics of an excellent detective as well.

She also has the sources of her own staff, who are meant to be unseen and unnoticed as they go about doing their business. The fact that people ignore servants and forget they’re present leaves plenty of opportunity for a maid to overhear something while straightening in the sitting room, or a footman to notice something while helping to serve dinner. And they’re far more likely to share that information with another servant than the authorities.

One might think that Phyllida wouldn’t have the time to properly investigate a crime when running such a vast household but, surprisingly, that’s not the case. An excellent housekeeper (which of course Phyllida is) would employ a competent staff, and therefore she would leave the bulk of the work to the housemaids, kitchen maids, footmen, and outside staff. She’s responsible for meeting with vendors and suppliers, paying their bills, and managing the menu, but most exceptional housekeepers had a surprising amount of time on their hands.

Would Mystery Author Agatha Christie Make a Good Amateur Detective?

In fact, they usually rose later than the rest of the household staff and would be served their meals and tea by lower-ranked servants. Only the butler would rank higher than the housekeeper—a fact that Mr. Dobble, Mallowan Hall’s butler, never hesitates to remind Phyllida.

As it turns out, all of these characteristics—along with the fact that Phyllida adores mystery novels—do assist her in solving the murder of Mr. Waring at Mallowan Hall. She manages to do so while continuing to manage a busy household filled with guests—even when one of her maids is murdered, and a footman goes missing.

Thus, in my mind, Phyllida was the far better choice for detective that Agatha Christie—even though the celebrated author was able to glean some ideas for her own works during the murderous events at Mallowan Hall. Whatever works, right?

Writing the Mystery Novel

During the Essentials of Mystery Writing workshop, you'll have the choice of creating a brand new mystery story from scratch or working with a story you already have in progress. Spend six weeks on your craft while receiving feedback from a published mystery author!

Click to continue.

From Script

TV Reboots, Utilizing Music to Create a Mood, and How to Grab Your Readers in Your First 10 Pages (From Script)

In this week’s round up brought to us by Script magazine, interviews with "Yellowjackets" creators Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson, showrunner Tracey Wigfield and EP Franco Bario of the "Saved by the Bell" reboot, highlights from WGFestival 2021, and so much more!

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 27

For the 2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. Today's prompt is to write a remix poem.

15 Promotional Ideas for Nonfiction Authors

15 Promotional Ideas for Nonfiction Authors

For the introverted writer, the process of promoting your book may seem to be a daunting, even frightening undertaking. Here, nonfiction author Rick Lauber lays out 15 promotional ideas for authors to get their books into as many hands as possible.

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 26

For the 2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. Today's prompt is to write a Well Blank poem.

Black Friday Savings 2021

Take Advantage of Our Black Friday Deals This Weekend

At Writer's Digest, there's no need to get up early or push and shove at stores to get your Black Friday deals. In fact, we give you the whole weekend to take advantage of them. Check them out here.

Plot Twist Story Prompts: Unexpected Break

Plot Twist Story Prompts: Unexpected Break

Every good story needs a nice (or not so nice) turn or two to keep it interesting. This week, your character receives an unexpected break or benefit.

The Joys and Challenges of Writing About Food

The Joys and Challenges of Writing About Food

Food takes on a main role in Annabel Abbs' novel, Miss Eliza's English Kitchen, where research incorporated all the senses. Here, she discusses the joys and challenges of writing about food.

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 25

For the 2021 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. Today's prompt is to write a thankful poem.

How To Turn an Idea Into a Chapter Book Series

How To Turn an Idea Into a Chapter Book Series

From finding the idea to writing the manuscript and sending it off to agents, author Christine Evans maps out how to turn an idea into a chapter book series.