Publish date:

3 Tips for Turning Rejection into Acceptance

Most of the experts will tell you that if a magazine editor rejects your idea, send it on to the next prospect on your list. This freelancer says you shouldn't give up too quickly on No. 1.

If you don't have inside connections, how do you get a foot in the publishing door?

Go through the back door, which is usually open just a crack. What's the back door? You've passed it any time you've ignored a personal rejection.

My first personal rejection was the result of a query I'd sent to a regional magazine with an international circulation. It was just five words: "Sorry, too small for us" and an editor's name.

I knew the magazine well and wrote back to the editor arguing that my article really was right for the publication. He said he liked my persistence—how about writing it from a different angle? I walked away with my first check.

How can you turn rejection into acceptance?

  • Don't take no for an answer. If you've done your homework and know your story is right for a specific magazine, tell the rejecting editor why. You, too, may have an editor say, "I appreciate your persistence." But beware—this strategy can backfire. Some editors don't take kindly to being told, in essence, that they're wrong. Be sure you're ready to take this risk before proceeding.
  • Don't overlook the long shot. A regional publisher rejected a cookbook idea of mine. I knew that the company's main focus was on nonfiction, but my market research had revealed it did publish a tiny amount of fiction. I queried the editor who'd sent me the personal rejection about a novel in progress and received an enthusiastic go-ahead.
  • Be adaptable. One magazine editor liked my writing but rejected a short story because she was unfamiliar with the unusual setting. I asked her if she'd be interested in an article about the setting. She bit.

When replying to a rejection, always be friendly, polite and professional. Thank the editor for her time in responding personally, remind her of who you are and what you've already sent her. Then follow up with a normal query letter, implementing one or more of the above suggestions. Who knows? Your next correspondence with this editor may include a contract and a check.

This article appeared in the September 2000 issue of Writer's Digest.

Tara Neilson is a freelance writer based in Alaska. Her work has appeared in publications such as Once Upon A Time, Ladybug, Joyful Child Journal, Alaska and Northwest Boat & Travel.

Why We Should Read Middle Grade Fiction as Adults

Why We Should Read Middle Grade Fiction as Adults

Young Adult fiction has surpassed its own demographic by being acceptable to read at any age. Why have we left middle grade fiction out of that equation? Here’s why we should be reading middle grade fiction as adults and as writers.

What Are the 6 Different Types of Editing?

What Are the 6 Different Types of Editing?

When you reach the editing phase of your manuscript, it's important to know what kind of editing you're looking for in particular. Author Tiffany Yates breaks down the 6 different types of editing.

WD Poetic Form Challenge

WD Poetic Form Challenge: Imayo Winner

Learn the winner and Top 10 list for the Writer’s Digest Poetic Form Challenge for the imayo.

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Print or Online Article First Place Winner: "Surfacing an Aquatic Diaspora"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Print or Online Article First Place Winner: "Surfacing an Aquatic Diaspora"

Congratulations to Elaine Howley, first place winner in the Print or Online Article category of the 90th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's her winning article, "Surfacing an Aquatic Diaspora."

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Script (Stage Play or TV/Movie) First Place Winner: "Jaguar Woman"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Script (Stage Play or TV/Movie) First Place Winner: "Jaguar Woman"

Congratulations to Olga El, first place winner in the Script (Stage Play or TV/Movie) category of the 90th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's her winning TV Pilot script, "Jaguar Woman."

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Non-Rhyming Poetry First Place Winner: "won't you celebrate with me"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Non-Rhyming Poetry First Place Winner: "won't you celebrate with me"

Congratulations to Nicole Adabunu, first place winner in the Non-Rhyming Poetry category of the 90th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's her winning poem, "won't you celebrate with me."

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Rhyming Poetry First Place Winner: "She Lives in Underbridge World"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Rhyming Poetry First Place Winner: "She Lives in Underbridge World"

Congratulations to MF Slattery, first place winner in the Rhyming Poetry category of the 90th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's the winning poem, "She Lives in Underbridge World"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Mainstream/Literary Short Story First Place Winner: "Tracks"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Mainstream/Literary Short Story First Place Winner: "Tracks"

Congratulations to Elizabeth Rosen, first place winner in the Mainstream/Literary Short Story category of the 90th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's her winning story, "Tracks."

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Genre Short Story First Place Winner: "A Brief Cameo"

Writer's Digest 90th Annual Competition Genre Short Story First Place Winner: "A Brief Cameo"

Congratulations to D. M. Ullrich, first place winner in the Genre Short Story category of the 89th Annual Writer's Digest Writing Competition. Here's his winning story, "A Brief Cameo."