Skip to main content

When Is Historical Accuracy Inaccurate?

Writers of historical fiction must always ride the line between factual and fictitious. Here, author Terry Roberts discusses how to navigate that line.

Those of us who write fiction about the past are constantly faced with questions about historical accuracy. It doesn’t much matter whether the past in question is a decade ago or a century ago, there are always those editors and readers who will challenge you over the use of a term or the placement of an object, almost as if reading historical fiction is something like an elaborate game in which you sift through the writer’s myriad details to pull out the one that doesn’t belong.

(How to Write Historical Fiction: 7 Tips on Accuracy and Authenticity)

When Is Historical Accuracy Inaccurate?

Changing the Fences

In my first novel, A Short Time to Stay Here, a well-intentioned editor at the small press who first printed it, was adamant about historical accuracy because she believed that readers depend on novelists to provide real history, real in this case meaning accurate down to the socks the characters were wearing and the music they were listening to. Fair enough, right up until the moment she discovered the height of the fences.

A Short Time to Stay Here is set in and around an internment camp built by the federal government during World War I to house German noncombatants, mostly the officers and crew of German merchant marine and passenger ships caught in American harbors when the U.S. declared war in April of 1917. The camp was constructed in the tiny hamlet of Hot Springs, North Carolina and included the Mountain Park Hotel, which was used to house the German officers. The novel itself was narrated by Stephen Robbins, a fictional character with no historical model, who had managed the hotel before the war and became the Inspector General of the camp during the internment. So far so good.

Late in the editorial process, the editor found a photo that showed part of the fencing around the camp, which revealed that it was only waist-high in places. My fictional fence was consistently 10-feet high and topped with barbed wire. She wanted it changed; I resisted. We went back and forth. My problem was that the plot of the novel depended on that fence in all sorts of large and small ways. If the characters could simply step over it whenever it suited them, then things began to unravel pretty quickly, including the psyche of the narrator.

Suffice it to say that I eventually won out, and the fences in A Short Time to Stay Here are 10 feet high to this day. Is that single historical detail accurate? Well, yes and no. Historically speaking, no; psychologically speaking, yes.

My Mistress' Eyes are Raven Black by Terry Roberts

My Mistress' Eyes are Raven Black by Terry Roberts

IndieBound | Bookshop | Amazon
[WD uses affiliate links.]

Changing the Timeline

My second novel, That Bright Land, is also set in the mountain of Western North Carolina, in this case during the summer of 1866, following the end of the Civil War. The plot of the novel depends in part on the number of men from WNC who fought for the Union army and who applied for federal disability from war wounds.

The disability investigations that serve as a cover for the narrator (who is chasing a serial killer) took place during the 1870s, but as the novel took shape, it became apparent that I needed to move the action up in time to create the sense of dramatic tension necessary to drive the plot.

In this case, neither editor nor reader ever noticed the historical discrepancy, but I was aware of it and made a conscious decision to tear 10 plus years off the calendar of little-known history, thereby changing the chronological setting of the action. The result? From the first page of That Bright Land to the last, there is a heightened sense of danger along with the rawness of unhealed wounds. Psychological wounds as well as physical.

When Is Historical Accuracy Inaccurate?

Changing the Actions

Few readers were familiar with the historical settings of A Short Time to Stay Here and That Bright Land, which made it easier to manipulate the details in order to create a more compelling story. That is not the case with my most recent novel. My Mistress’ Eyes Are Raven Black (due out in July 2021) is a thriller set on Ellis Island, itself a sort of American icon.

What gives this story its historical heft, however, is not the well-known physical setting but rather the place in time. During the 1920s, when the action occurs, America was in the throes of the eugenics movement. American sociologists were writing strident anti-immigration propaganda based on the pseudo-science of eugenics.

According to these commentators—men like Prescott Hall and Lothrop Stoddard—the pure Nordic strain of the American population was in danger of being infiltrated and replaced by the dark skinned, dark-haired, dark-eyed hordes who were assaulting our borders. Tragically, these same writers helped inspire what took place in Nazi Germany in the following decades.

Did a series of racist murders actually take place on Ellis Island in 1920, as described in My Mistress’ Eyes Are Raven Black? No, those events are entirely fictional and so, in a sense, historically inaccurate. Even so, the island seemed to me the perfect place to explore what was psychologically accurate about the period in which it was set, a period—like our own—in which we hated and feared the other.

When is historical accuracy inaccurate? When a slavish adherence to detail prevents the creation of a story that is more real than real. The beauty of historical fiction is that we don’t have to let accuracy in small things stand in the way of the truth in large things.

12 Weeks to a First Draft

Dive into the world of writing and learn all 12 steps needed to complete a first draft. In this writing workshop you will tackle the steps to writing a book, learn effective writing techniques along the way, and of course, begin writing your first draft.

Click to continue.

Romance Retellings of Literary Classics

Romance Retellings of Literary Classics

Author Chloe Liese makes a case for the romance genre being the natural home for retellings, and shares some tips on how to write a successful romance retelling of literary classics.

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 30

For the 2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. And now we're on Day 30.

Rae Meadows: On a Personal Passion Inspiring Literary Fiction

Rae Meadows: On a Personal Passion Inspiring Literary Fiction

Award-winning author Rae Meadows discusses how her lifelong love of gymnastics helped inspire her new literary novel, Winterland.

The Fae

The Fae

Every writer needs a little inspiration once in a while. For today's prompt, your character discovers that there are fae in their backyard.

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 29

For the 2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. Day 29 features our fifth (and final) Two-for-Tuesday prompt.

From Script

A Twist on the Holiday Romantic Comedy (From Script)

In this week’s round up brought to us by Script magazine, acclaimed filmmaker Charles Shyer shares with Script his twist on the holiday romantic comedy in his new film The Noel Diary, and more.

Sugar House Review Market Spotlight quote

Sugar House Review: Market Spotlight

For this week's market spotlight, we look at Sugar House Review, a nonprofit poetry publication based out of Utah.

November PAD Chapbook Challenge

2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge: Day 28

For the 2022 November PAD Chapbook Challenge, poets are tasked with writing a poem a day in the month of November before assembling a chapbook manuscript in the month of December. Day 28 is remix time.

Brian Lee Durfee: On Finishing a Fantasy Trilogy

Brian Lee Durfee: On Finishing a Fantasy Trilogy

Artist and author Brian Lee Durfee discusses what it felt like to write the final sentence in his Five Warrior Angels trilogy with his novel, The Lonesome Crown.