Skip to main content

FightWrite™: Fight Scenes With Magic

In this post, trained fighter and author Carla Hoch explores the process of writing fight scenes with magic—how to make the unbelievable believable, how limitations bring us closer to our characters, and more.

December is a magical time of year. So, the folks at Writer’s Digest thought it only appropriate for FightWrite™ to discuss fight scenes with magic. And that is yet another reason why I love them. Writer’s Digest speaks fluent Nerd year-round.

I have been helping writers with fight scenes for over five years now. Without question, the writers I mentor most are those of speculative fiction. And, because spec-fic includes basically everything with an element that doesn’t exist in reality, the majority of my work has centered around fight scenes with magic or fantastic qualities.

Magic in fight scenes is a vast and deep subject. By magic I also mean any super ability, not just the wizardly kind. I have a three-day conference lesson plan for it. I cannot cover every fine detail here but I will give the basics.

(FightWrite™: Authenticity Not Required)

Fights Scenes With Magic: Build It and They Will Come

Whenever anything in the world of your work deviates from the world we know, you are officially world building. And just like building anything, when you build a new reality for your reader, you have to create it from the ground up. That means first and foremost, establishing normalcy. Show the reader what to expect so that they will have the right reaction to the magical qualities in the work.

Establish Normalcy

From the opening scene of Star Wars: A New Hope, we know that the world we are about to enter is unlike our own. In fact, we are flat out told when we see the phrase, “Long ago, in a galaxy far, far away …” But, it’s not until about two minutes in that we actually get what all that means. We see the first spaceship, a Blockade Runner, being stalked by an Imperial Star Destroyer. From then on throughout the movie, whenever a space craft or strange being shows up, we might be fascinated, but we aren’t surprised—because those things are normal for the world we have walked into.

However, from the beginning of The Chronicles of Narnia, we learn that normal as we know it is the way things should be. That’s why we are as surprised as the Pevensie children at the existence of Narnia and all the magic it holds. We stop being surprised when the children are immersed in that world and it becomes both their, and our, new normal.

Fight Scenes With Magic: The Rules That Rule It All

So, how do we even begin creating worlds that have fantastic elements? Well, ironically, the way to show that anything bends the rules is to define the rules. That’s not the same thing as explaining them. You don’t have to explain the rules to your reader. You just have to establish them as fact and treat them as normal. Up until the movie The Last Jedi, the Force is never really explained. We know how it works but we don’t know why, and we are fine with that. We have accepted it as normal and very real in the Star Wars universe. So, don’t see the limits of fantastic elements as limiting. See them as legitimizing. They make the world real. Also, without defined limits in the world you create, you miss a crucial element in your fight scenes.

Fight Scenes With Magic: Physics Matter

The scientific laws of the world you create have a greater impact on the fight than the characters in it. Superman is super on Earth because Earth has much less gravity than his home planet of Krypton. Put Superman back on a planet with the gravitation pull of Krypton, and he’s not super. He’s just Kal-El, the man. Where Superman fights literally determines whether or not he is super.

Fight Write: How to Write Believable Fight Scenes

Fight Write: How to Write Believable Fight Scenes by Carla Hoch

IndieBound | Bookshop | Amazon
[WD uses affiliate links.]

Characters with super abilities must succumb to the natural laws of their surroundings. Your character may be able to punch like the Incredible Hulk. But if that character is in Zero-G, that punch will propel them and their target across the room or infinitely through space with the same force created by the punch. And when gravity is present, that same character with super strength will still not be able to stand and hold an item that outweighs them out in front of themselves. Not because the character isn’t strong, but because physics demands that the weight topple them forward.

Just as the fantastic properties of a world have limits, so do the fantastic powers of characters. Magical power must have a source and an end. If not, if a character is invincible—the story is over. Also, a character has to be able to suffer. No matter how un-human a character is, suffering will show their humanity and rouse the reader’s sympathies. We love the abilities of superheroes, but it’s their limits and the pain the limits cause that makes us love them.

Think about it, why do we love Batman? We shouldn’t, he’s a vigilante. He’s not out to make the world a better place because he is good. He wants it be a better place because he’s a tortured soul. For him, fighting evil is vengeance. He wants evil doers to suffer just as he did when his parents were gunned down in front of him. And that’s why we love him. We love brokenness in fantastic characters because in that way, we are like them. When we see a bit of ourselves in characters, we invest in them. The limits of a character’s ability, and especially when we take our character right to the threshold of those limits, is key to bringing our reader into the story and making them care that our character is in a fight.

Fight Scenes With Magic: Limits Lead the Fight

The rules governing the magic or super abilities of a character are also key when blocking a fight scene. How any character fights will be, in part, based on their natural/supernatural abilities. That ability governs their movement. A wizard who requires concentration to use his abilities may not be able to walk onto the battle field. The chaos may hinder his focus. So, in order to fight, that character may need to remain still and at a distance. But, if that wizard’s magic is channeled through a staff they carry, they may have to walk on the battle field to focus the energy of the staff on foes rather than friends.

FightWrite™: Fight Scenes with Magic

Fight Scenes With Magic: Feel It When They Deal It

The not-so-great thing about fight scenes that involve supernatural abilities is that they can distance the reader from the character with those abilities. We don’t know what it’s like to shoot lasers from our eyes or move things with our minds. But what we can relate to is physical sensation. Show what it feels like to emit that magic or use that super gift. What strain does it put on the one wielding it? And what is the cost of using that fantastic ability, and, yes, it should come at a cost. There has to be a balance. I will get back to that in a moment.

Along with how it feels to wield the gift, we have to show what it feels like to be on the receiving end of it. What injury does the magic or ability inflict? How does it wound? Not only does this make or break who wins the fight, it can determine the defense. How did Perseus defeat Medusa? He based his defense on her mode of attack. Medusa turned people to stone by locking eyes with them. Perseus made her see her reflection and her own power turned her into stone.

Fight Scenes With Magic: This Show Ain’t Free

Poor Medusa. If you know her story you know that she came by her horrible power honestly. And that power cost her just as every special ability costs anybody who has one. A character’s super abilities must cost them physically, socially, or emotionally. Using the Force wears down a Jedi. Superman has to wear a disguise in public. And every criminal Batman brings to justice reminds him of the one who killed his parents.

The price of using a gift is something with which we writers are intimately acquainted. Writing costs us. Physically it breaks us down, socially it isolates us, and mentally it grinds us into dust. So, why do we do it? Because the pain of ignoring the gift is greater than the pain of using it. It is the same for any character with a super ability, be they good or evil. Give them a compulsion to use it that supersedes the pain of wielding it. But make no mistake, that compulsion never erases the pain.

Goodness, I’ve only just begun with this subject. But this is a blog and not a book, and I have a word count limit. See! Limits are a reality on the page and off. I hope this post helps those of you who wax nerdy in our work. Be sure to check out my blog, FightWrite.net and my Writer’s Digest book, Fight Write: Writing Believable Fight Scenes. And, while you’re on your computer or phone, follow #fightwrite on Instagram for more fight writing tips, videos and book giveaways.

I hope your year’s end wraps you in magical wonder and that wonder fuels your writing for 2022. I look forward to new blog posts and possibilities to work with you all. Until next year, stay well, be blessed, and get blood on your pages.

FightWrite: What You Need to Know Before Writing Fight Scenes, Battles, and Brawls

Join expert instructor Carla Hoch in this video course to learn the three most important points for writers to consider before writing fight scenes, battles, and brawls! Using historical examples and real-world expertise, Carla will guide you through the entire process of determining why, where, and who—essential elements for the writer to understand in order to make the scene work properly.

Click to continue.

What Are Submission Guidelines in Writing?

What Are Submission Guidelines in Writing?

In this post, we answer the question of what are submission guidelines in writing, and we look at how writers can take advantage of them to find more success getting published.

3 Tips for Crafting a Character That Can Carry a Series

3 Tips for Crafting a Character That Can Carry a Series

From planting characteristics early on to understanding the expectations of your genre, author Mia P. Manansala shares 3 tips for crafting a character that can carry a series.

Quite the Reward

Quite the Reward

Every writer needs a little inspiration once in a while. For today's prompt, your character rescues a creature that turns out to be a powerful being.

Rita Zoey Chin: On the Way Storytelling Can Shape Lives

Rita Zoey Chin: On the Way Storytelling Can Shape Lives

Author Rita Zoey Chin discusses the process of writing her new novel, The Strange Inheritance of Leah Fern.

Chess Life: Market Spotlight

Chess Life: Market Spotlight

For this week's market spotlight, we look at Chess Life, the official publication of the United States Chess Federation.

The Art and Craft of Pre-Writing

The Art and Craft of Pre-Writing

What do you do when pantsing leads to false starts but plotting feels less organic? Author Christine Wells shares what she calls the art and craft of pre-writing, and a step-by-step system to help you succeed.

From Script

Learning About Your Characters Through Action (From Script)

In this week’s round up brought to us by Script magazine, read an exclusive interview with Raamla Mohamed, the creator, writer, and EP behind Hulu’s “Reasonable Doubt,” about stating the theme through a pivotal piece of dialogue and laying the groundwork for character development.

Mur Lafferty: On Adding a Science Fiction Spin on the Murder Mystery Novel

Mur Lafferty: On Adding a Science Fiction Spin on the Murder Mystery Novel

Author Mur Lafferty discusses the process of writing hew new science fiction myster novel, Station Eternity.

Courageous Discomfort: Thoughts on How To Have Important Conversations About Race and Racism for Writers, Readers, and Other Human Beings

Courageous Discomfort: Thoughts on How To Have Important Conversations About Race and Racism for Writers, Readers, and Other Human Beings

Authors Shanterra McBride and Rosalind Wiseman break down how to have important conversations about race and racism that can lead to actual change.