Skip to main content

How to Stay Objective and Improve Your Main Character

So how’s your relationship with your significant other going? The one with your heroine or hero, I mean. In a writer’s life, a main character is a very significant other. Now that my first published novel is about to be released, I realize how much I’ve learned about the writer-main character relationship. Guest column by Judith Rock, whose historical fiction debut, The Rhetoric of Death (Sept. 2010), received starred reviews from Publishers Weekly, Kirkus and Booklist.

So how's your relationship with your significant other going? The one with your heroine or hero, I mean. In a writer's life, a main character is a very significant other. Now that my first published novel is about to be released, I realize how much I've learned about the writer-main character relationship.

My first novel (unpublished) was written in first person. The main character was a female cop, an ex-dancer, in a small Florida town. I'm from Florida, and am an ex-dancer who was briefly a cop. I created a character to live out things I had not been able to live out myself.

Image placeholder title

Order a copy of Judith Rock's The Rhetoric of Death today.

Bookshop | Amazon
[WD uses affiliate links.]

My second book (also unpublished) featured her, but I switched to a close third person voice. Looking back, I think I changed the voice because I knew I'd created a Siamese twin and needed to separate us. A Siamese twin heroine is doomed to be only what the writer can be or has been or would like to be. The writer may need her too much emotionally, which can distort the writer's judgment about the book. Before I was a writer, I worked for many years as a professional choreographer. I learned that a time comes when a creator has to look dispassionately at the thing being created. You can't do that if what you've made is your Siamese twin. But if you can't look dispassionately at what you've made, you can't make it better. When neither book featuring my Siamese twin was bought, my agent said it was time to find another character and setting. I grieved as though part of me had died. Which it had.

When I finally found the main character I needed, he turned out to be a hero, not a heroine. And he's not only a man, he's a Jesuit, younger than I am, French, and living in the 17th century. We're not Siamese twins. But we care about many of the same things. People, loyalty, commitment, clear thinking, courage, figuring out what's true. We enjoy many of the same things. Dance—yes, he, too, has been a dancer—humor, cities, warm weather, good food. But, unlike me, he's living three and a quarter centuries ago. I do endless research to help him see, think, and react like a 17th century person. Though sometimes it's hard to get my 21st century tastes out of the way. For instance, in his time, everyone had at least occasional fleas and lice...

Your main character doesn't have to live three centuries ago or be the opposite gender to escape being your Siamese twin. But I do think that a writer's relationship with a main character should be full of discovery, push/pull, and surprise—like any good relationship. I'm convinced that if my guy were just another Siamese twin, he would not be on his way to publication and further series adventures!


Writer's Digest Tutorials

With a growing catalog of instructional writing videos available instantly, we have writing instruction on everything from improving your craft to getting published and finding an audience. New videos are added every month!

Click to continue.

online prompt 12:10

Imperfect Day

Every writer needs a little inspiration once in a while. For today's prompt, write about a perfect day gone awry.

Joseph Knox: On the Public Explosion of Grifters

Joseph Knox: On the Public Explosion of Grifters

In this interview, bestselling author Joseph Knox discusses how his fascination with grifters helped lead to his new thriller novel, Imposter Syndrome.

One Piece of Advice From Young Adult Fiction Authors in 2024

One Piece of Advice From 15 Young Adult Fiction Authors in 2024

Collected here is one piece of advice for writers from 15 different young adult fiction authors featured in our author spotlight series in 2024, including Kara Thomas, Ronni Davis, Amanda Glaze, Desmond Hall, Tiffany Wang, Samira Ahmed, and more.

From Script

Novelist Turned Showrunner Blake Crouch (From Script)

In this week’s round up brought to us by Script magazine, novelist turned showrunner Blake Crouch shares some challenges and rewards adapting his own work.

The Allure of a Novella: Why Writers (and Readers) Should Indulge, by Tara Deal

The Allure of a Novella: Why Writers (and Readers) Should Indulge

Award-winning author Tara Deal shares a reason for writers and readers to try novellas, including four tips for writing them and a sneaky good novella reading list.

Cale Dietrich: Figure Out What Works for You

Cale Dietrich: Figure Out What Works for You

In this interview, author Cale Dietrich discusses putting a queer spin on a rom-com favorite with his new romance novel, The Rules of Royalty.

Land a Book Deal in 2025

Land a Book Deal in 2025

Think like an industry insider who makes decisions every day on what work merits print publication, plus more from Writer's Digest!

What the Death Card Revealed About My Writing Career, by Megan Tady

What the Death Card Revealed About My Writing Career

Award-winning author Megan Tady shares how receiving the death card in relation to her future as an author created new opportunities, including six new habits to protect her mental health.

T.J. English: Making Bad Choices Makes for Great Drama

T.J. English: Making Bad Choices Makes for Great Drama

In this interview, author T.J. English discusses how he needed to know more about the subject before agreeing to write his new true-crime book, The Last Kilo.