Why do I have to revise according to an editor's suggestions? My work is written exactly how I want it. How do I know an editor's criticism is valid?

Author:
Publish date:

Beginning Writer's Answer Bookedited by Jane Friedman

Writers who are new to the business sometimes consider an editor’s requests for revision a personal affront, when in reality the editor is only trying to get the best possible manuscript for her market. Editors know what works for their audience, and have the experience and expertise necessary to objectively criticize work. If you don’t want to revise your manuscript to the editor’s style or suggestions—and you could be right—you can always withdraw the work, if it comes to that. But there’s a good chance you will never get your work published if you don’t learn to take constructive criticism from editors.

Image placeholder title

Authors who have been in the game a long time and have published dozens of books are typically the most open to revision suggestions. Some beginners find this fact paradoxical, but it isn’t once you consider that seasoned authors have attained a level of professionalism and experience that’s taught them to respect the editor’s eye.

Both magazine and book editors are eager to help you achieve your best efforts. If there are occasional misunderstandings along the way, the writer should not overlook the editor’s essential goodwill toward her work.

Amorak Huey: On Stalling Out After Publication

Amorak Huey: On Stalling Out After Publication

Poet Amorak Huey hit a creative roadblock after publishing his latest poetry collection Dad Jokes From Late in the Patriarchy. He shares his cure (and more!) in this article.

From Script

New Original Podcasts, Videos, and Understanding Data as a Screenwriter (From Script)

In this week’s round-up brought to us by ScriptMag.com, Script releases brand new audible and visual content!

Summer Writing Activities for Writers

8 Summer Writing Activities for Writers

Summer is upon us, so here are 8 summer writing activities for writers to consider as the temperature rises.

Books and Authors to Check Out in 2021

71 Books and Authors to Check Out in 2021!

Need a book to read in 2021? Want to find a new author to check out? Then, explore this list of 71 books and authors featured in our author spotlight series in a variety of genres.

How Do I Get My Poetry Published?

How Do I Get My Poetry Published?

Learn how to get your poetry published, whether you're trying to get a poem or an entire book of poems published.

Dyslexia Is a Writer's Superpower (With Help)

Dyslexia Is a Writer's Superpower (With Help)

Author PJ Manney shares how dyslexia, dysgraphia, and dyscalculia should not be viewed as impediments to becoming a writer. Rather, they should be viewed as writing superpowers, especially when paired with certain technologies.

Plot Twist Story Prompts: Falsely Accused

Plot Twist Story Prompts: Falsely Accused

Every good story needs a nice (or not so nice) turn or two to keep it interesting. This week, have a character get falsely accused for something.

By Any Means Necessary: Finding Unorthodox Ways to Break-In

By Any Means Necessary: Finding Unorthodox Ways to Break-In

Novelist D. Eric Maikranz gives advice for how to get your readers to sit up and take notice of your work in untraditional ways.

M.M. Chouinard: On Jumping From One Project to Another

M.M. Chouinard: On Jumping From One Project to Another

Novelist M.M. Chouinard immediately started writing her second book after finishing her first and shares here why that was the best decision she could have made.