The Secret To A Stronger Nonfiction Book Proposal

Knowing what’s already on bookshelves may just be the single most effective (and most overlooked) way to convince an agent where your idea fits in. Here’s how your Competitive Analysis can be your secret weapon.
Publish date:

Knowing what’s already on bookshelves may just be the single most effective (and most overlooked) way to convince an agent where your idea fits in. Here’s how your Competitive Analysis can be your secret weapon.

This guest post is by Nina Amir, the Inspiration to Creation Coach, who is the bestselling author of How to Blog a Book and The Author Training Manual. A speaker, blogger, and author, book, blog-to-book, and high-performance coach, she helps people combine their passion and purpose so they move from idea to inspired action and positively and meaningfully impact the world as writers, bloggers, authorpreneurs, and blogpreneurs. Some of Nina’s clients have sold 300,000+ copies of their books, landed deals with major publishing houses and created thriving businesses around their books. She is the founder of National Nonfiction Writing Month, National Book Blogging Month, and the Nonfiction Writers’ University. As a hybrid author, she has published 15 books and had as many as four books on an Amazon Top 100 list at the same time. To find out more about Nina and get a free goal-achievement e-book, visit Receive a set of free blog-plan templates when you visit or a free guide to writing a nonfiction book at


It’s a rare book that is “the only one” of its kind. If you want to create a successful nonfiction book proposal, you need to go to the trouble of producing a Competitive Analysis.

A client of my book coaching business once had a book idea resulting from a talk she’d been asked to give for an organization. The more she prepared her presentation, the more excited she became about the topic: women and leadership. In researching her talk, she’d already gone through a process similar to outlining a Table of Contents, and she’d even come up with a catchy acronym for her approach. Here’s the problem she faced: This writer had no idea how many other books already existed on the topic of women and leadership—my quick search on Amazon yielded more than 20,000 results. Not only that, she had not considered:

  • How her book would be different from the others
  • If the category required another book on the topic
  • How to make her book stand out.

The more I explained how a successful nonfiction book had to be both unique and necessary—how it had to “fill a hole on the shelf in the bookstore”—the more she felt that her great idea no longer sounded so good. In fact, it still might have been a great idea. But she needed to be strategic in shaping it. She needed to evaluate her book concept against the competition, and show how it would rise above it.

[Want to land an agent? Here are 4 things to consider when researching literary agents.]

Conduct a Solid Competitive Analysis

In the “Competing Books” or “Competitive Analysis” section of your proposal, you provide agents and acquisitions editors with a detailed look at other books on your topic and how yours compares. The savviest authors also use this information to improve the book idea they’re proposing—until it’s one an agent or publisher can’t say no to.

You may think stiff competition bodes poorly for your book. In truth, if there are many bestsellers in your category, that proves a market exists for books like yours. If you can show that your idea offers new benefits to readers, you can make a case that it will sell just as well—if not better.

Conversely, a category with few books and little competition could represent an opportunity to dominate the niche, if you can load your proposal with facts that show how your book is unique and necessary and that a market exists for it.

  1. Taking into consideration your book’s category and topic, compile a list of competing titles (books that cover similar information or tell a similar story) by searching physical bookstore and library shelves as well as sites such as Amazon, Barnes & Noble, LibraryThing, Goodreads, Book Depository, Red Room and general search engines.
  1. Consider the following factors, looking carefully at each of the competing books you’ve identified:
  • How does it differ from the book you want to write? Is the scope of the book different? How so? Does it have different benefits? What are they?
  • How is it similar to the book you want to write?
  • What are its pros and cons?
  • How would you improve upon it?
  • What promises does the author make to readers?
  • What promises does the author fail to make that he could or should have (or that you can)?
  1. Study reviews of the competing books you have identified. You can learn a lot from what readers think is good, bad or missing. Plan to include in your book the things that are weak or absent in the competition.
  1. Visit competing authors’ websites. See what else you can learn about their books’ sales, market, readership, etc.
  1. Look at the competing authors’ bios. Consider:
  • What are the authors’ credentials (or lack thereof)? How do yours compare?
  • Will it help or hurt you to have different qualifications or similar ones?

[The Top 10 Elements of a Book People Want to Read

Use the Analysis to Improve Your Idea

  1. Ask yourself: Is there a hole on the shelf in your category? What sort of book is missing? Describe the “perfect” book to fill that hole. Now, how does your book idea compare to the book you just described? Are you offering something other authors have not delivered? Make a list of things you need to do to stand out in your niche.
  1. Based on your evaluation, decide if you need to make changes to your concept. Drawing on the factors you identified in all the steps leading up to this point, strengthen your idea so that it:
  • Tells a fresh story
  • Offers a different perspective or new angle
  • Presents a compelling argument that other authors have not made
  • Provides different data or more current information
  • Takes readers on a singular journey.
  1. Compare your credentials to that of the competing authors you have identified.
  • Are you equipped to join the ranks of these authors? What do you need to do or be to compete with them? Do you need a larger platform? What steps can you take to broaden your expertise or reach?
  • What else can you do to show that you are the best person to write this book at this time?

[Learn How to Become a Travel Writer in 6 Simple Steps]

  1. Once you've made your book’s concept as original and necessary as it can possibly be, add your Competitive Analysis to your book proposal. Narrow the competition t o five you feel are the closest (and strongest, favoring books that seem to have sold well)
    in comparison to your own project. For each one, list the title, subtitle, author, publisher, copyright year, number of pages, format (paperback or hardcover) and price. Then summarize how it’s similar to your idea (or how it helps readers) as well as how it’s different.

Finish this section with a brief paragraph about how your book stands out from the competition as a whole.

Boost your proposal-writing skills and chance of publication with
The Weekend Book Proposal. Jam-packed with proven strategies,
sample queries and proposals, and more, this book is a must-have.
Order it now and have your proposal finished in 48 hours!

Thanks for visiting The Writer's Dig blog. For more great writing advice, click here.


Brian A. Klems is the editor of this blog, online editor of Writer's Digest and author of the popular gift bookOh Boy, You're Having a Girl: A Dad's Survival Guide to Raising Daughters.

Follow Brian on Twitter: @BrianKlems
Sign up for Brian's free Writer's Digest eNewsletter: WD Newsletter

Shawn Nocher: On Letting Your Characters Lead

Shawn Nocher: On Letting Your Characters Lead

Author Shawn Nocher discusses how thinking deeply about her characters lead her to a breakthrough when crafting her debut novel A Hand to Hold in Deep Water.

Poetry Prompt

Wednesday Poetry Prompts: 570

Every Wednesday, Robert Lee Brewer shares a prompt and an example poem to get things started on the Poetic Asides blog. This week, write a summer poem.

How I Sold the Cover of My Latest Book as an NFT and What I Learned

How I Sold the Cover of My Latest Book as an NFT and What I Learned

When faced with the difficult task of promoting his novel Catch 42: A novel about our future, writer Felix Holzapfel had a wild idea: Why not use non-fungible tokens?

Bridget Morrissey: On Taking the Leap from YA to Adult Fiction

Bridget Morrissey: On Taking the Leap from YA to Adult Fiction

Author Bridget Morrissey explains the differences in her process for writing her first adult debut, Love Scenes, compared to her YA novels, what she wanted to explore in adult fiction, and more!

WD Poetic Form Challenge

WD Poetic Form Challenge: Awdl Gywydd Winner

Learn the winner and Top 10 list for the Writer’s Digest Poetic Form Challenge for the awdl gywydd.

Kara Holden: On Adapting a Person's Life for the Screen

Kara Holden: On Adapting a Person's Life for the Screen

Screenwriter Kara Holden shares her experience with writing the script for Clouds on Disney+, and how she decided what moments of her subject's life to include in the film.

4 Tips for Setting a Novel in a Place You Don’t Know Well

4 Tips for Setting a Novel in a Place You Don’t Know Well

You want to write your story in a place you're not familiar with, but how can you do it justice? Kim Hooper, author of No Hiding in Boise, has some tips.

Alka Joshi: On Allowing Characters to Inform Your Sequel

Alka Joshi: On Allowing Characters to Inform Your Sequel

In this article, historical fiction author Alka Joshi explains how the characters from her first book inspired the sequel, The Secret Keeper of Jaipur, and how their story managed to surprise her.