To Show or Not to Show Your Quotes

Hey Everyone,

Many of you are already familiar with my “Questions & Quandaries” column in the print version of Writer’s Digest, but now I’m entering the blogosphere–that’s right, they’re crazy enough to have me blogging. Of course, I tried negotiating for a fancier office, a nicer parking spot and 3 free breakfasts a week, but they countered with, well, nothing, so I settled for having my mug at the top.

I’m hoping most of you are as excited about this as I am, as each week I’ll try to give you insight into some of your grammatical, ethical and business-oriented questions. Ask me anything you want ( ) and I’ll do my best to answer as many as I can. So kick off your shoes, get comfortable and get ready to learn all the writing secrets you’ve always wanted to know. — BAK

Q: Recently, a source for an article that I wrote asked if she could read it before I submitted it.  I said no.  She insisted it was her right to read any direct quotes I’d attributed to her before submitting the article. After the article was published, she was displeased that the editor had cut out some of what she considered “important information.” Did I do the right thing?—Meg Charendoff

A: Like any true ethical dilemma, there are no clear-cut rules on this subject. Some writers have no reservations about showing quotes to their interview subjects, while others think it’s one of journalism’s 10 mortal sins (somewhere between plagiarism and writing in passive voice). After all, once it’s been said, it’s fair game.

“Generally, newspaper reporters don’t allow interviewees to look over quotations and turn down requests when a source asks,” says Michael Bugeja, director of the Greenlee School of Journalism and Communication at Iowa State University. The reason behind this is that you’re catching open and honest responses the first time around; any revisions will only allow for sources to replace honest answers with lifeless rhetoric.

Freelancers working on investigative pieces, on the other hand, tend to take a slightly softer approach, says Bugeja. “Magazine writers usually have to provide a fact-check for their quotations, and so they send the transcript of the interview back for clarification.” If you decide to go this route, it’s important to preface the fact-check with this statement: Please correct any errors of omission or fact only. In fact, highlight it, underline it, send an e-card repeating it. If you don’t stress that you’re strictly looking for factual errors, you allow them to change everything. And, as any editor knows, if you give someone a chance to edit themselves, they will.

Some magazines have their own rules, so you may want to check with the one signing your paycheck. Writer’s Digest’s policy is clear: No revisiting quotes. If I’m working on a feature and unsure about a quote or particular fact, I’ll call with a follow-up question to clarify, possibly getting a new quote all together. If the interviewee wants to see his quotes, I politely say, “While I can’t share the interview transcript, I’d be happy to talk again, and allow you to add or clarify anything you want.”

The truth is, it’s completely up to you and rests solely on what you feel comfortable doing. If you want to show the quotes, show them. If you don’t, don’t. The key to remember, though, is this: You don’t have to show quotes to any of your interviewees. As long you’re willing to stand behind it, there’s no need to let them revisit their words. They said them. You heard them. Case closed.

And, if you want to avoid this all together, just record your interviews. If you have it on tape, there’s no dispute.

Take care of yourself and your writing,
Brian A. Klems

You might also like:

  • No Related Posts

13 thoughts on “To Show or Not to Show Your Quotes

  1. Steven M. Nesbit

    Hi Brian,

    I just discovered your column. Being a retired English teacher and a Free lancer I was captivated by it. So here’s one for you.

    What would be correct in this sentence?

    "There are three (to, two, too)’s in the English language."

    And why?


  2. Lisa Abeyta

    This is for the sole purpose of allowing Maria to view you doing the chicken dance. She really deserves that, you know?

    By the way – great photo. You sound so knowledgeable that I had you pegged as one of those old, curmudgeonly editors who smokes a cigar and has crumbs in his salt-and-pepper beard. What a surprise to see I’m probably older than you (and no beard yet).

  3. Julie

    This blog is a great idea. You mention recording your interviews. I agree this is the easiest way to avoid trouble, but am I legally allowed to record a phone interview? I thought there was some rule about this…thanks.

  4. Natasha Yim

    Hi Brian,

    Wow! You sure are handsome. Okay, that probably won’t get me a byline in Writer’s Digest, but it was worth a try.

    Enjoyed your response. I just finished an interview for an article I’m writing, and your answer came at just the right time.

    Good luck on the blogging. I’m looking forward to reading more.

  5. Karen Phillips

    Brian, your answer jibes with everything I’ve observed and heard from other experienced writers. Thanks for this new blog to which I plan to refer often! (And the picture works: you look like a funny, likeable, intelligent guy, which vastly outweighs a gorgeous, conceited, empty-headed one. Besides, I’m happily married and old enough to be your older sister, if not mother.)

  6. Carra

    I must admit this is the first time I am reading Questions and Quandaries and I must say, the answer provided was perfect (in my eyes). I personally found it very usefull, since I am trying to get into the freelance writing myself and know nothing about journalism’s 10 mortal sins. I will definitely follow Questions and Quandaries very closely! Have a nice day.

  7. Soly Paraiso

    H1, Brian!
    Wow!Am I glad I subscribed to your Questions and Quandaries. I’ve been a fan of yours since Kevin Alexander left the Writer’s Digest
    Magazine, (or did he?) You two have a great sense of humor and I love it! (I didn’t know you are so young! and so goodlooking too!)
    Now my question is: I’ve been writing articles in one of the local papers here in our hometown. The Editor/Publisher of the paper knows me personally. But I’ve never been paid for my work.
    Do I have the right to ask for some conmpensation for my articles?
    Thank you, brian, and more power to you!


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.