Poetry FAQs: Having what it takes to be a poet

Earlier this week, I received a long e-mail from an anonymous Poetic Asides reader who asked important questions I’m sure all poets have asked themselves at some point or another in their poetic development. Here’s some of the e-mail:

“I want to put together a book of poetry. I have the subject already in mind. Here’s the thing. I am a fly-by-night poet. I have a hard question for you. Do you think I have what it takes to make it as a poet from having read some of my work?

“I sent in six poems to a local competition this year and didn’t make it even as an honorable mention. I also sent in five or six to the Writer’s Digest competition in December. I haven’t heard anything, so am assuming that I didn’t make the cut. Now we are talking 100 poets who made it, and I didn’t get there.

“Anyway, I turn to you in a moment of despair. I am feeling low and just want a crumb to pull me out of this mist. However, honesty is what I need.”

And my honesty is what this poet will get.

First, I don’t advise poets to try thinking about putting together books of poetry until they’ve published some individual poems. It’s not that a poet can’t do this, but by entering competitions, I’m assuming that a poet wants some kind of recognition, and publication is a great form of recognition.

Second, contests are great, but they are competitions, which means there are several other poets battling it out for the top poem(s). If Writer’s Digest recognizes 100 poets, for instance, then they must receive thousands of entries for the competition. Keep in mind that most competitions produce a minority of winners and a majority of losers.

Third, I’d suggest spending less time entering competitions and instead submitting to online and print publications that publish poetry that fits your style. Yes, this means you should devote time to reading online and print journals to see what fits. (Note: This is also a great way to learn from what works and doesn’t work in other poets’ poems.)

Fourth, it sounds like you need involvement with other poets, whether online or in person. I would suggest trying to get a small critique group together, either by contacting other poets online or trying to do so locally–either through your local library or bookstore. You’d be surprised how many poets are all around us.

Finally, only you can say if you have what it takes to be a poet. Do you feel compelled to write poems even facing the possibility that no one will ever read your work? If so, you are and will always be a poet. Poetry is not a form of writing that will earn you much fortune and glory, so using recognition as your “poet worth” gauge is probably not the best idea.

However, recognition can be a powerful fuel for the poetic motor. So get involved with some other poets; read and submit to publications; and keep writing. The rest will take care of itself.


You might also like:

  • No Related Posts

5 thoughts on “Poetry FAQs: Having what it takes to be a poet

  1. Sean

    Had to write in and say how much I appreciated this advice.

    I write for myself and, very occasionally, the missus. I’ve never submitted so much as a haiku for publication but I still consider myself a poet.

  2. Anthony Buccino

    " I also sent in five or six to the Writer’s Digest competition in December. I haven’t heard anything, so am assuming that I didn’t make the cut. Now we are talking 100 poets who made it, and I didn’t get there."

    I sent in poems in May and haven’t heard anything, either. But, then again, I haven’t heard from contests I entered in January, either, so, maybe it’s them?

    As for the other advice. Right on. When you think your poem is finished and perfect, put it away and don’t look at it for a few weeks. Then when you read it, you’ll see things you missed before.

    It can take five minutes or an hour and five minutes to write a poem, but weeks or months or more to finish it. In my case, that is.

    I have a work in progress that has had 13 poems published in variious places, about 25%, but I’m still working on it day after day even though an earier version is sitting in a pile of contest entries somewhere.

    After a few thousand poems, they start to write themselves. That’s one way to know if you are a poet. Another way is to see everything you do flash before your eyes in verse. That gets weird sometimes.

    OK, enough of this. Back to the craft.

  3. David

    Since you’re suggesting a poet submit for publication, I’d like to suggest they borrow or buy a copy of "Poet’s Market."

    This annual publication lists most online and print publishers and what materials they are looking for. It tells if they pay, how much, how many submissions they receive a year and how many they accept. There are good articles on how to write a cover letter, write a query, track your submissions, etc. This book improves your odds of publication measurably.

    And do familiarize yourself with the type of material the editors accept. My first rejection simply said, "We don’t publish religious poems." I didn’t think mine were religious, but I understood what the editor meant. I hadn’t read his magazine.

    Submitting to a themed call for submissions is another great way to increase your odds of publication. I’ve seen calls for cowboy poetry, poems by nurses, poems by Italian poets, poems by prisoners, etc. If you fit the bill, send your best work in.

    Addressing the idea of the book though, really, who is going to buy another book of poetry? I’ll tell you who, people that know you. So get known. Get out and read in public. When people see you, you want them to tell their friends, "Hey, here’s Mike, he’s the neighborhood poet."

    I self-published my first chapbook because so many people asked when I was going to do a book. I had the thing practically pre-sold and had even better success with the second chap.

    Good luck,